In a country that prides itself on reverence for all life forms, the contradiction between cultural ideals and the harsh reality of animal cruelty is deeply jarring. India’s Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (PCA), passed in 1960, has remained largely unchanged for over six decades—despite the rise in awareness, documented abuse cases, and persistent calls for reform. At the heart of the struggle to bring this issue into the national spotlight is former Union Minister and lifelong animal welfare activist Maneka Sanjay Gandhi.
In an exclusive interview with PgGinger, Mrs. Gandhi speaks candidly about the gaps in India’s current legal framework, systemic enforcement failures, and why animals still remain voiceless in the corridors of power. Her responses are unfiltered, firm, and compassionate—a rare trifecta in Indian politics.
Legal and Policy Gaps
Why has reforming India’s 1960 animal cruelty law proven so difficult?
“The PCA Act remains unreformed because animals don’t vote. Politicians respond to voting constituencies, and despite the growing concern among citizens, animal welfare continues to be treated as a fringe issue.”
The current penalties under the PCA Act are disturbingly outdated. In a world where inflation and social progress have reshaped many laws, animal protection has remained frozen in time. Gandhi reveals that although amendments have been drafted and pushed through numerous times, they’ve faced opposition from industries that economically benefit from the exploitation of animals.
“These amounts might have been sufficient in 1960; but today, they’re absurd. I’ve been fighting for amendments for decades, but we face entrenched opposition.”
She adds that without continuous, strategic pressure from a coalition of MPs, advocates, and everyday citizens, reforms will continue to stall.
Enforcement and Ground Reality
How seriously do authorities take animal cruelty cases today, and what systemic changes are needed?
“The enforcement situation is appalling… I can tell you that an animal cruelty complaint has less priority than a stolen bicycle. This isn’t hyperbole—it’s the daily reality we face.”
The root issue, she explains, is a lack of training and awareness among police personnel. Many officers are unaware of the laws protecting animals, and FIRs often aren’t even filed. Gandhi highlights the urgent need for mandatory training modules across all ranks of the police and judicial systems.
“We need prosecutors specifically trained in animal law… The National Crime Records Bureau must begin formally tracking animal cruelty cases across India.”
Without formal tracking and prioritisation, cases of animal abuse remain invisible, and victims—both animal and human—are let down.
Public Attitudes and Cultural Contradictions
Do you feel Indian society still sees animal cruelty as a minor issue? How can that perception change?
“Indian society remains deeply contradictory on animal welfare. We worship cows yet leave them to eat plastic on the streets. We revere elephants yet chain temple elephants until their legs develop abscesses.”
Gandhi doesn’t shy away from pointing out uncomfortable truths. The cognitive dissonance in how animals are treated, versus how they are symbolised, is evident. Education and awareness, she insists, are the only long-term solutions.
“Educational institutions must incorporate mandatory animal welfare education. Religious leaders must speak out against practices that cause suffering, regardless of tradition.”
Still, she sees promise in India’s youth—those who are increasingly more conscious, questioning, and willing to change long-standing norms.
“Education and awareness are the most powerful tools for changing mindset and societal attitudes.”
Comparative Perspectives
Could India benefit from an approach like the FBI’s, which tracks animal cruelty as a serious offense?
“Absolutely! The FBI didn’t begin tracking animal cruelty out of sentimentality; they did it because the data shows that animal abusers often escalate to human victims.”
Gandhi warns that without a centralised animal crime registry in India, repeat offenders go untracked and unpunished. A robust monitoring system could help not only prevent animal cruelty but serve as an early warning system for broader violence in society.
A Wake-up Call for Public Safety
Have you encountered cases where cruelty to animals was an early sign of more dangerous behavior?
“Countless times. Let me share a case… CCTV recorded a man stabbing puppies. Weeks later, we learned he was abusing his partner too.”
Such stories, chilling as they are, form the backbone of Gandhi’s advocacy: protecting animals isn’t just about animals—it’s about creating a safer, more empathetic society for all.
“Nearly every serial killer or mass shooter globally has animal abuse in their background. The evidence is overwhelming.”
The Way Forward
What are the most urgent legal and social reforms India needs for better animal protection?
For Gandhi, the path forward is crystal clear. It includes the passage of the Draft PCA Amendment Bill 2022, the creation of functioning State Animal Welfare Boards, integration of animal welfare into education, training for veterinarians, and public awareness campaigns against cultural practices that cause unnecessary animal suffering.
“We must address institutionalised animal exploitation… The dairy industry is particularly cruel.”
She also advocates for a national movement towards veganism, not just as a trend, but as an ethical and compassionate lifestyle choice.
Civic Engagement and Youth Leadership
How can young Indians and the public play a more active role?
“Change happens when ordinary citizens refuse to look away from suffering.”
Gandhi’s advice to young people is practical and empowering:
- Document evidence of cruelty.
- File complaints and follow up.
- Organise locally and form recognised welfare groups.
- Engage politically and make compassionate choices.
She urges youth to link animal welfare to other critical issues: public health, mental well-being, crime prevention, and environmental sustainability.
“Animal welfare isn’t separate from human welfare… by fighting for animals, you’re creating a more compassionate society for everyone.”
Final Thoughts
This conversation is not just a policy dialogue—it’s a call to action. Mrs. Maneka Sanjay Gandhi is right: protecting animals is not optional for a civilised nation. It is a moral, legal, and cultural imperative that affects every layer of our society.
With greater awareness, legislative reform, and societal courage, India can become a true global leader in compassion and justice for all living beings.
For more interviews and stories on issues that matter, follow PgGinger.
